Login | Search:
Home | About Us | News | Events | Resources | ShowBiz | Directory | Gallery | Contact Us

Home : News : Book Reviews


Artist in Spotlight
Association for Jewish Theatre
Book Reviews
Boston Stage
Call for Proposals
Children & Young people's Theatre
Conferences & Symposiums
David's Front Line
Editor's Notes
Ellen Schiff's Shelf
European Association for Jewish Culture - EAJC
Festival in Spotlight
Film Reviews
First Curtain
From Page to Stage
Global Arts Initiative
Holocaust Theatre On line Collection (HTC)
Info Center
Introduction to Jewish Theatre
Israeli Theatre Worldwide
Jacobo Kaufmann
Jewish Intercultural Performance Group
Kaleidoscope on New York Stage
Magazine Reviews
Merchant of Venice
Michael's Corner
New Publications
Open Space
Open Stage - Intercultural Junction
Philadelphia Stage
Play Reviews
Production Point
Productions on Tour
Recommended Website
Research & Collections
Revisiting the Past
Solo Performance - Online Catalogue
Spanish / Español : Artículos
Spanish / Español : Noticias y actividades culturales
Story Theatre
Success Story
The Arab- Israeli Melting Pot
The Bible on Stage
The European Research Center
The New York Scene
The Next Generation
Theatre and Physics
Theatre in Spotlight
Upfront Europe
What's New in Israel ?
What's New in London ?
What's New in Washington DC ?
What's Next ?
What's up in Australia ?
What's up in Europe ?
Yiddish Theatre

Email Page
Post Comment

Yiddish Proletarian Theatre: The Art and Politics of the Artef, 1925–1940. By Edna Nahshon
By Dr. Brian Horowitz

Yiddish Proletarian Theatre: The Art and Politics of the Artef, 1925–1940.

By :Edna Nahshon.

Publisher :Westport: Greenwood Press, 1998. 260 pp.

Edna Nahshon, Professor of Yiddish at the Jewish Theological Seminary, takes us through the history of the Artef, the radical Yiddish dramatic troupe based in New York during the heyday of the Yiddish theater in America. Begun in the mid-1920s as a study group of amateur worker-actors (at one time there were nine separate studios with over 120 students), in the 1930s the troupe went professional, putting on at least two and often three new plays per season. With such plays as Jacob Mostel's Strike, Shmuel Godiner's Jim Kooperkop, Avrum Vevioka's Diamonds, and Maxim Gorky's Egor Bulychev and Dostigaev and Others, Artef spread propaganda to the masses. Since the Artef is alive almost exclusively in archival material and secondary scholarship on radical or Yiddish theater, this book is a welcome event in Yiddish studies.

Ideologically Artef was far left; its hope was a Communist society here in America. As a troupe, its role was "agit-prop," to agitate and propagandize, to serve as the cultural representative of radical workers. In fact, most of its tickets were pre-sold through worker unions and, at least in its early years, Artef gave presentations at political events. Its first large-scale production was Mass Play and Ballet of the Russian Revolution, which appeared at the Lenin memorial celebration in Madison Square Garden on January 21, 1928.

Although Nahshon refrains from treating the paradox of ideology versus artistic quality in radical Yiddish theater, the book raises important questions on this issue. It appears from her study that when one of the two had to be sacrificed, it was always aesthetics, since ideology was the raison d'être of the company. As one might expect, the troupe often put on plays that were ideologically acceptable, but without artistic merit; examples are Avrum Vevioka's The Steppe on Fire or Mark Daniel's Four Days.

Artef's greatest artistic and commercial successes were connected with the talented productions of director Benno Schneider. Schneider, who had been active in the Zionist Habima troupe in Moscow, wed aesthetic excellence to revolutionary ideology with his interpretation of Aristocrats, an adaptation of Sholem Aleichem's Mentshn. Incidentally, Schneider earned such a positive reputation with Artef that he received offers to direct on Broadway, a promotion that cost the radical Yiddish theater dearly.

The end of the Artef was gradual, and its causes were closely associated with the reduced role of Yiddish in American life. But there were bright lights before the darkness. During the "days of the Popular Front," when the Communists formed associations with less radical leftist parties, the Artef attracted a larger audience, which led to an optimistic expansion that later was responsible for huge financial losses. The darkness occurred at the end of the thirties, when the number of Yiddish speakers began to diminish. The last performance of the Artef was on July 7, 1941. Nahshon poetically describes the end: "A flicker. The last spark. The flame died" (204).

Although this work is well-researched, Professor Nahshon strangely fails to distance herself from Artef's politics. Her silence reveals her approach of empathizing with her subject, which prevents her from placing the radicalism of the Artef and its pro-Soviet orientation in historical perspective. For example, she often sides with the Artef viewpoint, quoting without authorial commentary the carping of Artef managers against the "bourgeois" theater on Second Avenue and against liberals or other less non-radicals. Moreover, it is a shame that Nahshon does not deal with the issue of Jewish content, considering the reader aware of the fact that for the members of the Artef the Jewish religion was something retrograde and inimical. Nevertheless, the troupe spoke in Yiddish and put on the stage adaptations of the works of Mendele and Sholem Aleichem. Therefore, even if Artef's sponsors spurned religion, it seems necessary to discuss what role they assigned to Jewish national identity.

To sum up: Professor Nahshon has done a fine job giving us a tour through the history of Artef and in this narrow task she deserves the highest praise. The flaws in this book reflect an absence of broader speculation. Nevertheless, the scholar of diaspora Jewish thought and culture who tries to answer the big questions will be extremely grateful for Nahshon's excellent research.

About Dr. Brian Horowitz
University of Nebraska

Source: South Atlantic Review

Related Links:

  • Resources
  • Read additional book reviews

    Bookmark    Print    Send to friend    Post a comment  

    There are currently 73 comments about this article:

      ,     (12/2/2007)
    2.fake oakleys
      fake oakleys, fake oakleys    (10/17/2013)
    3.Hermes Birkin Outlet
      Hermes Birkin Outlet, Hermes Birkin Outlet    (10/20/2013)
    4.woolrich woolen mills upland jacket
      woolrich woolen mills upland jacket, woolrich woolen mills upland jacket    (10/25/2013)
    5.michael kors outlet online
      michael kors outlet online, michael kors outlet online    (11/19/2013)
    6.replica gucci zoo
      replica gucci zoo, replica gucci zoo    (11/22/2013)
    7.Retro 11
      Retro 11, Retro 11    (12/11/2013)
    8.Jordan 11 Bred
      Jordan 11 Bred, Jordan 11 Bred    (12/12/2013)
    9.Jordan 11 Bred
      Jordan 11 Bred, Jordan 11 Bred    (12/13/2013)
      http://www.pinterest.com/Bred11s, http://www.pinterest.com/Bred11s    (12/13/2013)
      http://www.pinterest.com/Bred11s, http://www.pinterest.com/Bred11s    (12/14/2013)
    12.British Bred 11s Black Friday
      British Bred 11s Black Friday, British Bred 11s Black Friday    (12/14/2013)
    13.jordan retro 11s concord
      jordan retro 11s concord, jordan retro 11s concord    (12/14/2013)
      http://www.pinterest.com/Bred11s, http://www.pinterest.com/Bred11s    (12/15/2013)
    15.Retro 11
      Retro 11, Retro 11    (12/15/2013)
    16.Jordan 11
      Jordan 11, Jordan 11    (12/15/2013)
    17.Cheap Jordan 11 Gamma Blue
      Cheap Jordan 11 Gamma Blue, Cheap Jordan 11 Gamma Blue    (12/15/2013)
    18.Jordan 11 Bred
      Jordan 11 Bred, Jordan 11 Bred    (12/15/2013)
    19.Jordan 12 Taxi
      Jordan 12 Taxi, Jordan 12 Taxi    (12/15/2013)
    20.Bred 11s
      Bred 11s, Bred 11s    (12/15/2013)
    21.Jordan 11
      Jordan 11, Jordan 11    (12/15/2013)
    22.Gamma Blue 11s For Sale
      Gamma Blue 11s For Sale, Gamma Blue 11s For Sale    (12/15/2013)
    23.British Cheap Ugg Black Friday
      British Cheap Ugg Black Friday, British Cheap Ugg Black Friday    (12/17/2013)
    24.Ugg Outle
      Ugg Outle, Ugg Outle    (12/19/2013)
    25.cheap mulberry wallets
      cheap mulberry wallets, cheap mulberry wallets    (12/22/2013)
    26.jordan 11 restock
      jordan 11 restock, jordan 11 restock    (12/23/2013)
      http://www.pinterest.com/gammablue11sale/jordan-11-gamma-blue, http://www.pinterest.com/gammablue11sale/jordan-11-gamma-blue    (12/23/2013)
    28.Jordan 11 Bred
      Jordan 11 Bred, Jordan 11 Bred    (12/23/2013)
    29.Cheap Jordan 11 Gamma Blue
      Cheap Jordan 11 Gamma Blue, Cheap Jordan 11 Gamma Blue    (12/23/2013)
    30.Taxi 12s For Sale
      Taxi 12s For Sale, Taxi 12s For Sale    (12/23/2013)
    31.Jordan 12 Taxi
      Jordan 12 Taxi, Jordan 12 Taxi    (12/23/2013)
    32.grape 5s
      grape 5s, grape 5s    (12/23/2013)
      http://www.bred11ssale.net/, http://www.bred11ssale.net/    (12/25/2013)
    34.mulberry cheap bags
      mulberry cheap bags, mulberry cheap bags    (12/25/2013)
    35.discount mulberry handbags
      discount mulberry handbags, discount mulberry handbags    (12/26/2013)
    36.wholesale mulberry bags
      wholesale mulberry bags, wholesale mulberry bags    (12/29/2013)
    37.wholesale mulberry handbags
      wholesale mulberry handbags, wholesale mulberry handbags    (1/1/2014)
    38.discontinue mulberry navy blue purse
      discontinue mulberry navy blue purse, discontinue mulberry navy blue purse    (1/1/2014)
    39.Taxi 12s
      Taxi 12s, Taxi 12s    (1/3/2014)
    40.gamma blue 11s
      gamma blue 11s, gamma blue 11s    (1/3/2014)
    41.Taxi 12s
      Taxi 12s, Taxi 12s    (1/3/2014)
    42.gamma blue 11s
      gamma blue 11s, gamma blue 11s    (1/3/2014)
    43.bred 11s
      bred 11s, bred 11s    (1/3/2014)
    44.bred 11s
      bred 11s, bred 11s    (1/3/2014)
    45.Taxi 12s
      Taxi 12s, Taxi 12s    (1/3/2014)
    46.bred 11s
      bred 11s, bred 11s    (1/3/2014)
    47.grape 5s
      grape 5s, grape 5s    (1/3/2014)
    48.gamma blue 11s
      gamma blue 11s, gamma blue 11s    (1/3/2014)
    49.mulberry wallets for cheap
      mulberry wallets for cheap, mulberry wallets for cheap    (1/4/2014)
    50.mulberry black letters
      mulberry black letters, mulberry black letters    (1/4/2014)
    51.bred 11s
      bred 11s, bred 11s    (1/9/2014)
    52.cheap mulberry
      cheap mulberry, cheap mulberry    (1/10/2014)
    53.cheap michael kors outlet
      cheap michael kors outlet, cheap michael kors outlet    (1/14/2014)
    54.mulberry classic tote t2133
      mulberry classic tote t2133, mulberry classic tote t2133    (1/14/2014)
    55.gamma blue 11
      gamma blue 11, gamma blue 11    (1/16/2014)
    56.Taxi 12s
      Taxi 12s, Taxi 12s    (1/16/2014)
    57.grape 5s
      grape 5s, grape 5s    (1/16/2014)
    58.gamma blue 11s
      gamma blue 11s, gamma blue 11s    (1/16/2014)
    59.gamma blue 11s
      gamma blue 11s, gamma blue 11s    (1/16/2014)
    60.Taxi 12s
      Taxi 12s, Taxi 12s    (1/16/2014)
    61.grape 5s
      grape 5s, grape 5s    (1/16/2014)
    62.grape 5s
      grape 5s, grape 5s    (1/17/2014)
    63.michael kors tote bags
      michael kors tote bags, michael kors tote bags    (1/17/2014)
    64.cheap mulberry purses
      cheap mulberry purses, cheap mulberry purses    (1/17/2014)
    65.bred 11s
      bred 11s, bred 11s    (1/17/2014)
    66.order mulberry handbags
      order mulberry handbags, order mulberry handbags    (1/20/2014)
    67.mulberry bags cheap
      mulberry bags cheap, mulberry bags cheap    (1/23/2014)
    68.cheap michael kors outlet
      cheap michael kors outlet, cheap michael kors outlet    (1/23/2014)
    69.mulberry cheap
      mulberry cheap, mulberry cheap    (2/16/2014)
    70.mulberry for cheap
      mulberry for cheap, mulberry for cheap    (2/16/2014)
    71.jordan 11s all black
      jordan 11s all black, jordan 11s all black    (4/4/2014)
    72.jordan 11 concord kicksonfire
      jordan 11 concord kicksonfire, jordan 11 concord kicksonfire    (4/14/2014)
    73.cheap jordan shoes
      cheap jordan shoes, cheap jordan shoes    (4/17/2014)

  • Edna Nhashon

    Copyright © 2002 - 2014 All About Jewish Theatre. All rights reserved.
    Concept and Content by NCM Productions | Graphic Design by Sharon Carmi | Programming by Tigersoft, Ltd.
    Privacy Policy | Site Map | Contact Us